Carmie's BBQ & Grill - Tiffin,OH Menu

French Onion Soup

Our house made, fan favorite French Onion Soup stuffed full of caramelized onions, 2 slices of garlic butter French baguette and topped with bubbly provolone cheese

Loaded Brisket Fries

Hand-cut fries topped with chopped Brisket, diced tomatoes, banana peppers, diced red onion, shredded mozzarella and cheddar cheese and your choice of BBQ sauce

Southwest Phenom Burger

Our house pressed beef patty cooked to your preferred temperature and covered with pepper jack cheese, jalapeños, fried corn tortilla strips and Cajun mayo and one included side.

Espresso Apple Crisp

Sarah’s scratch apple crisp made up of cinnamon spiced apples, oat and brown sugar crumble and topped with her specialty espresso caramel glaze

Battered Mushrooms

Lightly battered mushroom caps served with our Alabama white sauce!

Cheese Curds

Battered Wisconsin cheese curds served with our signature cayenne horseradish sauce

Frickles

Hand breaded pickle chips fried to a perfect crisp and served with our signature cayenne horseradish sauce

Mac n Cheese Bites

Kraft mac and cheese balled and breaded and fried up and served with our homemade ranch to dip

Mozzarella Sticks

6 Italian breaded mozzarella sticks served with a side of marinara

Onion Ring App

Beer battered and fried, a healthy portion of onion rings served with a side of our signature cayenne horseradish sauce

Pretzel Bites

Salted pretzel bites served with our beer cheese to dip

Shrimp Basket

Delicious breaded butterfly shrimp served with house cocktail sauce!

Carmies Loaded Nachos

Loaded freshly fried nacho chips topped with your choice of chicken or pork, shredded lettuce and tomatoes with salsa and sour cream on the side. Jalapenos and Carolina BBQ come with the pork. Chicken nachos come with carmie's sweet BBQ.

Crispy Chicken Salad

Lettuce topped with our crispy chicken chunks, bacon, tomatoes and shredded cheddar cheese and your choice of 1 dressing.

Chef Salad

Lettuce, topped with ham, turkey, bacon, diced tomatoes, egg, Cheddar & Mozzarella cheese and served with your choice of 1 dressing.

Chunks Full

Hand breaded chicken tenderloin chunks in a full pound portion size tossed in your choice of 2 sauces.

Chunks Half

Hand breaded chicken tenderloin chunks in half pound portion size tossed in your choice of 1 sauce.

Wings12ct

12 jumbo smoked chicken wings fried to order and tossed with your choice of 2 sauces.

Wings 6ct

6 jumbo smoked chicken wings fried to order and tossed in your choice of 1 sauce.

Alabama Chicken Sandwich

Smoked pulled chicken, bacon, diced tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, onion rings and our famous Alabama white sauce

Breaded Perch Sandwich

Hand breaded lake perch topped with tomatoes, lettuce and house made tartar sauce

Brisket Sandwich

Slow smoked beef brisket on a toasted bun and topped with your choice of 1 BBQ sauce and Carolina coleslaw and sliced pickle chips.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Smoked pulled pork on a toasted bun topped with your choice of 1 BBQ sauce and sliced tomatoes and onion.

Carolina Pork Wrap

Grilled flour tortilla filled with pulled pork, cheddar and mozzarella cheese, Carolina slaw, sliced pickles, southern BBQ and Carolina BBQ sauce.

Chef Richard Brisket Wrap

Flour tortilla with smoked beef brisket, banana peppers, lettuce, diced tomatoes, mozzarella, cheddar, Cajun Mayo & Carolina BBQ sauce

Club Wrap

Traditional turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, diced Tomatoes & Mozzarella cheese wrapped in a flour tortilla

Crispy Chicken Wrap

Freshly diced breaded chicken chunks, lettuce, diced tomatoes, Bacon & Cheddar cheese wrapped in a flour tortilla

5X Grilled Cheese

Grilled sourdough bread topped with American, provolone, Swiss, Cheddar & Parmesan cheese

5X Stuffed Grilled Cheese

5x grilled cheese stuffed with your choice of smoked chicken or smoked pulled pork and topped with your choice of 1 BBQ sauce.

Brisket Melt

Grilled sourdough 5x cheese sandwich topped with smoked beef brisket, banana peppers, onion rings and southern BBQ sauce

5x Patty Melt

Our 5x Grilled Cheese stuffed with a hand made patty cooked to your preferred temperature

All-American Burger

The all American way - our specially blended ground beef Patty topped with sliced tomatoes, pickle slices, lettuce and mayo

Mac Attack Burger

Specially blended ground beef Patty topped with our Mac & cheese, Bacon & Tater tots

Shroom Burger

Specially blended ground beef patty, sauteed mushrooms and onions, fried pickle chips, Swiss Cheese & Alabama sauce

Roadhouse Burger

Specially blended ground beef Patty topped with smoked pulled pork, bacon, cheese, onion Rings & Honey BBQ sauce

Half Rack Ribs

Smoked baby back ribs

Full Rack Ribs

Smoked baby back ribs

Seneca Pit Platter - Pick 3 & 1 Side

The little bit of everything dinner! Your choice of 3 meat options - pulled pork, brisket, 3 cheese chicken, 4 chicken wings - your choice of 2 BBQ sauces on the side

Beef Brisket Dinner

Slow smoked beef brisket

Pulled Pork Dinner

Smoked pulled pork

Three Cheese Chicken

Smoked chicken breast topped with cheddar, mozzarella and parmesan cheese

Bourbon Chicken Dinner

Tender chicken breast topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, diced onions, diced tomatoes and bourbon BBQ sauce.

Breaded Perch Dinner

Hand breaded lake perch served with a side of our house made tartar sauce

Pork Mac & Cheese Bowl

Smoked pulled pork smothered on top of our southern Mac & Cheese and topped with your choice of 1 BBQ sauce

Brisket Mac & Cheese Bowl

Famous smoked brisket smothered on top of our southern Mac & Cheese and topped with your choice of 1 BBQ sauce

Cbr Flatbread

Toasted flatbread topped with chicken, homemade ranch sauce, tomatoes and bacon.

Bourbon Chicken Flatbread

Our house specialty bourbon BBQ smothered on a toasted flatbread and topped with smoked pulled chicken and mozzarella cheese.

Cheesecake Bites

Rolled and fried seasonal flavored cheesecake dusted with powdered sugar and a side of seasonally complimentary dipping sauce

Brisket Green Beans

Smoked diced beef brisket tossed with green beans and smoked beef tallow and our signature dry rub

Broccoli

Steamed to order freshly cut broccoli

Carolina Slaw

Sweet and tangy, vinegar based coleslaw

Creamy Slaw

Classic creamy coleslaw

Fried Redskins

Diced and fried redskin potatoes tossed in salt and pepper

Garden Salad

House salad mix topped with sliced red onions, cherry tomatoes and homemade croutons with your choice of 1 dressing

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Whipped redskin potatoes

Rolls & Butter

2 freshly baked rolls served with butter on the side

Pork Rinds

Made in house pork rinds tossed in our signature dry rub

Smoked Baked Beans

Smoked in house baked beans with our smoked pulled pork and our house blend of secret seasonings!

Southern Mac & Cheese

House made macaroni and cheese sauce blended with shell pasta topped with our signature dry rub

Tater Tots

Fried and tossed in Salt & pepper, crispy and fluffy tater tots